PAYDIRT!
Chromium cleanup begins after 11-year legal fight
Tuesday, April 04, 2006
By KEN THORBOURNE
JOURNAL STAFF WRITER
Dump trucks loaded with chromium-contaminated soil began rumbling
out of Hudson County's largest waste pit yesterday - the culmination
of an 11-year legal war waged by a Jersey City nonprofit.
"I had a tear in my eye," said the Rev. Willard Ashley, co-chair
of the Interfaith Community Organization, as the first dump trucks
rolled out of the 36-acre Roosevelt Drive-In site off along Route
440 near Duncan Avenue. "A lot of people thought this would never
happened."
In May 1995, Ashley's group sued the Honeywell Corporation to
compel the chemical giant to remove roughly 1 million tons of
chromium-saturated soil at the site. After years of appeals and
debate over what constitutes an adequate environmental fix, a
four-year cleanup effort begins.
U.S. District Judge Dennis Cavanaugh granted ICO its wish in
2003, ruling the Morris Township chemical company would have to
carry out a complete excavation. To move things along, Cavanaugh
also named former U.S. Sen. Robert Torricelli "special monitor" for
the court-ordered cleanup.
As he situated himself for the next four years of his life
yesterday, Honeywell's construction manager Joseph Besca explained
that each of 40 trucks will remove 24 tons of soil from the site
every day.
To protect the public, the soil - which is being trucked 177
miles to a facility in Northhampton, Pa. - is "burrito-wrapped" in a
heavy material, Besca explained. This method eliminates the chance
for particles of the known carcinogen to escape into the air, he
said.
In Pennsylvania, the dirt will be loaded onto rail cars and sent
to Idaho, where it will be dumped in a landfill, Besca said. The
excavation began in the southeast corner of the site, which is
bordered by the Hackensack River on the west and Route 440 on the
east.
Even after Cavanaugh's decision in 2003, Honeywell continued to
fight in court. Last October Honeywell filed a revised remediation
plan, supported by attorneys and a key chromium expert who
originally advised the ICO. That plan - which would have shaved $200
million off the $400 million pricetag for a full excavation - argued
that half the soil could be left in place and "capped" by a
protective seal.
Cavanaugh disqualified the change-of-heart attorneys and expert
in January on the grounds they violated "judicial integrity."